The state known as “The Lone Star” state is about to get very lonely for a couple of Dallas Stars’ players after being singled out publicly by none other than the team President. In an public outburst leaving the entire NHL world scratching its head, Jim Lites decided to rip apart the team’s best two players, captain Jamie Benn and his assistant Tyler Seguin… and everyone around the league has taken notes. What remains to be seen is what grade they gave Lites who, according to many, crossed the line.
First and foremost, if you were living under a rock over the last few days, let’s take a look at what Lites had to say.
“They are fucking horse-shit, I don’t know how else to put it,” Lites said. The team was ok. But Seguin and Benn were terrible.” (quote from Sean Shapiro of The Athletic)
The quotes were taken from Sportsday – The Dallas News. For your convenience, I’ll post them here:
“It’s pissed me off,” Lites said. “What nobody says is what is completely obvious to me: We are getting terrible play from our top two players.”
“We pay these players to be the best players on our team and they are consistently out-efforted and outperformed by everybody else’s best players.”
“If 14 and 91 don’t lead, we will not be successful. I think this is the most talented and deep team we’ve had in years here.
“Certainly, this is the best team that we’ve put together from a talent perspective since Tom Gaglardi’s owned the franchise. Tom has allowed us to do everything we needed to do to be successful. Whatever it’s taken, he’s done. And I am tired of getting emails from him saying ‘What the hell is going on with our best players?'”
“He’s (Seguin) playing on the periphery. I’ve been in the business forever. I’ve been with Steve Yzerman in bad seasons, and what you’ll find is goal-scoring is a dirty business. You’ve got to go to hard places. And Tyler, last year, I saw him really perform and get into the difficult spots. This year, I’ve seen him as a weak forechecker, slow to the action and not getting it done.
“And he’s hit a lot of posts. He’s had some bad puck luck. But he’s not getting dirty. I don’t know what it is. I’m not accusing him of being without character, but we’re not getting it done.”
“Jamie Benn hasn’t scored a goal from longer than 5 feet all year. He makes plays in the neutral zone that if my kid had done it in squirts, he’d be benched. Am I wrong? He turned the puck over three times yesterday on plays if Denis Gurianov had done that, he wouldn’t have seen the light of day.”
“The owner and I see this the same way. We expect our best players to perform like other team’s best players, to be accountable, to have attention to detail, to have responsibility on the ice and off and get the job done for us. And it’s not getting done. Game in, game out, the best players on other teams are outplaying the best players on our team.”
“The coach has to, the GM has to, the owner has to, the CEO has to. I have to fricken hold these guys accountable and be part of the process of getting these guys to play to their best. … We don’t question their desire to win, but they think it’s easy, and that’s what bothers me. There’s just too much complacency in their games. Lack of attention to detail, and that’s what we need. Accountability and attention to detail and hard work.”
“The frustration I have is there were times where I think ‘Geez, we’re not getting any secondary scoring.'” Lites said. “But we’re not getting any primary scoring.”
“This team shouldn’t even be thinking about missing the playoffs. It shouldn’t even be an issue. We are too talented, too good, too strong to be performing this poorly.”
My first reaction after reading those comments was one of surprise. It’s not every day that you see a professional athlete get nailed to the wall like that. It’s even less common when it comes from the team President. And when he does it to his best two players, it’s unheard of.
Then I got thinking that maybe, he had talked to them in the past and saw no signs of improvement or willingness to improve. If that were the case, it could be a last ditch effort to get them motivated and if that failed, they would then consider moving one of them, or both.
I don’t play for him
“I don’t play for him,” Benn said. “I play for every player in this room and the coaching staff. I come to the rink and, like I said, I’m proud to be a Dallas Star and proud to go out there every night and battle with these guys in games. I’ve really put my teammates first.”
“Obviously, I read the article, and it is what it is,” Benn said. “People have their opinions on the outside. All it really is is noise. I think knowing there’s a situation within the organization, I try to keep it within the organization and deal with it face to face. With that being said, I come to the rink every day and wear the Dallas Stars jersey proudly and play hard for the fans and my teammates in here.”
“A little bit of a surprise there, because I didn’t know how he felt,” Seguin said. “It came as a bit of a surprise. I said it yesterday at practice. I understand I need to be better. Jamie understands he needs to be better. We need this team to be better, the organization to be better. I think everyone is frustrated over the last few years, and it came out yesterday.”
That was until I read the questions to Benn and Seguin, and subsequently, their answers. It was the first time they had heard that the President and the owner were not happy with their performances. Never were they approached with the exception of talks with head coach Jim Montgomery. Now I’m worried that with this outing, Lites has done some irreparable damages not only to Benn and Seguin, but to the Dallas Stars’ franchise. Who in their right mind will want to sign there as a UFA with a loose cannon at the helm?
Further, Lites might have tied his team’s hands in the even of a trade, by painting his players as ones who aren’t professional in not paying attention to details. Yes, there is a chance that Benn and Seguin will up their play but there’s also a huge chance that the players in the dressing room range behind their teammates and not care anymore.
In the only game the Stars have played since the comment, a 5-1 Dallas win over the Detroit Red Wings, Benn (39GP, 15G-15A-30Pts) played 15:07, with only two shots on goal to show for. Seguin (39GP, 11G-22A-33Pts) had 17:59 minutes of ice time, only managing one shot on goal although recording an assist on the powerplay.
In my humble opinion, Lites’ outing is a huge risk, one that no President or owner should take. Can you imagine had Geoff Molson come out that way against Carey Price when his play wasn’t up to par earlier this season? My oh my… Go Habs Go!